The New York Islanders once again found themselves down a defenseman Thursday night, losing Ryan Pulock to an apparent lower-body injury late in the second period against the Winnipeg Jets.
Islanders radio broadcaster Alan Fuehring said two Jets trainers helped Pulock through the Jets’ tunnel because he couldn't put any weight on his injured leg.
The injury occurred without contact as Pulock was skating backward through the neutral zone.
It’s a concerning development for the Islanders, especially since Pulock returned to the lineup last Thursday after missing four games with an upper-body injury stemming from his previous shoulder injury.
Regardless of what the advanced metrics might suggest, Pulock remains a glue guy for the Islanders’ defensive structure.
That was evident during his recent four-game absence, when the Islanders struggled to maintain the defensive structure that has been so important to their success.
Now, they could be without him again.
Whether it’s been injuries to Alexander Romanov or Pulock, the Islanders have turned to free agency to fill holes on their blue line, bringing in Logan Stanley and Ben Hutton.
Stanley has been a strong addition, though he’s now missed two straight games with a lower-body injury. He did skate Thursday morning, and he could return Saturday against the Detroit Red Wings.
Hutton, meanwhile, has had his moments.
But there’s a difference between finding players who can plug holes and acquiring players who can help take an organization to the next level.
Whether the Islanders are healthy or dealing with injuries, general manager Mathieu Darche will eventually have to address that.
Of course, the Islanders already have one of those players in Matthew Schaefer.
But for the 19-year-old and the franchise's long-term future, they need more.
Schaefer has carried this team for much of the season, especially the back end. When he’s off the ice, the Islanders simply aren’t the same defensively.
That’s not a sustainable formula for a team hoping to become a legitimate Stanley Cup contender.
At some point, this aging blue line needs an upgrade, preferably with a player who fits Schaefer’s timeline and can grow alongside him.
With Pulock’s latest injury serving as another reminder of just how thin things can get defensively, that need is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.
Which brings us to Detroit Red Wings defenseman Simon Edvinsson.
The Islanders have some promising young defensemen in the pipeline, including 2026 No. 16 pick Malte Gustafsson, 2025 No. 17 pick Kashawn Aitcheson, 2026 fifth-round pick Vladimir Dravecky, and 2022 fourth-round pick Isaiah George.
But the team still needs to bring in someone from outside the organization.
While the Romanov acquisition on Day 1 of the 2022 NHL Draft hasn’t worked out quite how the organization envisioned, that’s the type of move the Islanders should be looking to make.
Romanov received an eight-year extension worth $6.25 million annually on July 1, 2025, only to suffer season-ending injuries in consecutive seasons: a shoulder injury in November 2025 and a torn right ACL in October 2026.
The Islanders took a chance on a young defenseman they believed could be part of their future.
Unfortunately, injuries have gotten in the way.
But that shouldn’t deter Darche from making another move for a young defenseman with significant upside.
The guy to get has been, and continues to be, Simon Edvinsson.
Happy Free Friday!
Why Edvinsson?
More news has emerged regarding Edvinsson’s situation over the last few days, particularly concerning potential offer sheets.
Several teams have reportedly tried to get the 23-year-old left shot to sign one, but Edvinsson is concerned Detroit would match, keeping him with an organization he seemingly no longer wants to play for.
Edvinsson wants a change of scenery, preferably before the Dec. 1 deadline.
If he doesn’t sign an NHL contract by then, he’ll be ineligible to play for the remainder of the 2026-27 NHL season, including the Stanley Cup Playoffs.
The Islanders should be all over it.
There are so many reasons to like Edvinsson if you’re the Islanders, who have inquired, as Darche does with any player on the market.
Just like Schaefer, Edvinsson isn’t a one-trick pony. He’s a strong two-way defenseman who can contribute at both ends of the ice.
He has the size, mobility, and skill set to make an impact, and at 23, he’s nowhere near his ceiling.
There’s another factor worth considering: Long Island has become an attractive destination.
Between UBS Arena, the lifestyle Long Island offers, and the emergence of Schaefer as one of the NHL’s brightest young stars, there’s plenty to like about where this organization is headed.
For a 23-year-old looking for a fresh start, the chance to grow alongside Schaefer and potentially become part of the Islanders’ next competitive window should appeal.
Having fellow Swedes Simon Holmstrom, Emil Heineman and Victor Eklund in the organization certainly can’t hurt.
Of course, none of that guarantees Edvinsson will want to come to Long Island, but the Islanders have a compelling pitch.
Acquiring him is one thing. Paying him is another.

The latest annual average value being floated is approximately $11 million, up from the $9 million to $10 million range reportedly being discussed when this situation began.
That’s a substantial commitment, especially with Schaefer eligible to sign a long-term extension beginning July 1, 2027, and Simon Holmstrom potentially in line for a significant raise of his own.
But I wouldn’t automatically rule the Islanders out because of Edvinsson’s reported asking price.
Look at Noah Dobson.
Dobson was reportedly seeking somewhere between $10 million and $11 million annually from the Islanders before ultimately signing an eight-year deal worth $9.5 million annually after being acquired by the Montreal Canadiens.
There’s no guarantee Edvinsson would take less to play elsewhere, but his demands may be part of an effort to force Detroit’s hand.
The Islanders have some financial flexibility moving forward, with several contracts coming off the books and decisions to make regarding their pending free agents.
There’s also the question of Romanov’s future, particularly before his full no-trade clause kicks in on July 1.
The Islanders will have additional flexibility with their veteran defensemen beginning July 1, 2027, when Ryan Pulock ($6.15 million AAV) and Scott Mayfield ($3.5 million AAV), both signed through 2029-30, see their full no-trade clauses become 16-team modified no-trade clauses.
Adam Pelech, who carries a $5.75 million cap hit through 2028-29, already has a 16-team modified no-trade clause, while Tony DeAngelo’s two-year, $9 million extension includes a three-team no-trade list.
That doesn’t mean the Islanders will move any of their top-four defensemen, but Darche will have options if he wants to reshape his blue line.
The point is that there are ways to make the money work if Darche believes Edvinsson can become a cornerstone of this blue line.
That’s what this decision should ultimately come down to.
What Would It Cost?
This is where things get interesting.
This past summer, Darche wasn’t inclined to move any of his top prospects, wanting to see what they could do in their first years of professional hockey.
Although the sample size remains small, I’d think he’d be willing to move a prospect or two for the right player, and Edvinsson certainly feels like one of those players.
I’m sure the Red Wings would love to get their hands on Victor Eklund, but I just don’t see Darche entertaining that idea, especially with the 20-year-old putting himself in the Calder Trophy conversation.
I do wonder about Cal Ritchie.
Detroit reportedly wants to acquire a young center as part of its long-term plans.
Ritchie has shown plenty of potential, but he’s also dealt with injuries during his first two professional seasons, and his play has been inconsistent at times.
With the Islanders’ current situation, it's fair to wonder how they view Ritchie’s long-term fit.
Bo Horvat ($8.5 million AAV) and Mathew Barzal ($9.15 million AAV) are in the fourth year of their respective eight-year contracts, both running through 2030-31. Jean-Gabriel Pageau ($4.85 million AAV) is in the first season of his new three-year deal, which runs through 2028-29, while Brayden Schenn ($6.5 million AAV) has one more season remaining on his contract after this one, through 2027-28.
Don’t rule out Casey Cizikas returning on a one-year deal, depending on how things shake out.
Now, I’m not saying the Islanders don’t need young centers. They absolutely do, especially with Danny Nelson, their next-best center prospect, projecting as more of a bottom-six player at the NHL level.
Nelson, currently in his third season at the University of Notre Dame alongside his two brothers, is expected to join the organization following his junior season.
But the Islanders don’t necessarily have an immediate, pressing need at center.
Yes, Ritchie can play the wing, and he’s a talented player the Islanders shouldn’t move unless they’re getting serious quality in return.
Edvinsson would certainly qualify, but I’m skeptical the Islanders would have much appetite to move a player they think so highly of, one who still has so much potential.
Then there’s Aitcheson.
With the defensive depth the Islanders have in the pipeline, I wonder whether Darche would consider moving him.
Aitcheson has had some growing pains in his first professional season, which isn’t surprising given the jump from junior hockey.
His skating remains an area for development, especially given how much mobility factors into Pete DeBoer’s system.
But Aitcheson brings a different element with his physicality, and there’s plenty of reason to believe he can become an impactful NHL defenseman.
Still, would that make him untouchable in a potential deal for Edvinsson?
I don’t think so.
What about Cole Eiserman?
He’s currently sidelined with an upper-body injury, believed to be a facial fracture, and has had some growing pains during his first professional season.
But few prospects have his natural goal-scoring ability, and the Islanders shouldn’t give up on someone with that kind of offensive upside.
He still has development ahead, particularly in his all-around game, but that’s part of the process for a young player adjusting to professional hockey.
Could a package built around Aitcheson or Eiserman, plus draft picks, entice Detroit?
What about Ritchie as the centerpiece of a potential deal?
I’m not suggesting the Islanders should simply throw these players into trade talks.
Each has legitimate upside, and Darche has to be careful not to sacrifice too much of the organization’s future.
Also, don’t forget about draft picks.
The Islanders could use picks to complement a package built around a prospect or potentially make draft capital the centerpiece of an offer.
I’m not suggesting Darche should mortgage the future, especially with Schaefer just beginning what could be a special career.
But Edvinsson is only 23.
This wouldn’t be sacrificing the future for a short-term fix or acquiring a veteran for one or two playoff runs.
It would use future assets to acquire an established NHL defenseman who could immediately join the Islanders’ young core, potentially anchoring a defensive pair for the next decade.
That’s the kind of move worth seriously considering.
Of course, the Islanders would have to get this one right.
There’s little room for error in the Schaefer era.
How Would Edvinsson Fit?
Edvinsson is a rangy, mobile, left-shot defenseman who could become a cornerstone of the Islanders’ blue line for the next decade, and the best part is that he wouldn’t necessarily have to play alongside Schaefer.
In fact, I’d argue the Islanders would be better off separating them.
Imagine having Schaefer driving one defensive pair and Edvinsson anchoring another.
That gives DeBoer more flexibility with matchups, more mobility throughout his defensive corps and, most importantly, another difference-maker who can impact the game when Schaefer isn’t on the ice.
The Islanders desperately need that.
Yes, few NHL teams have two elite defensemen.
More often, elite teams have an elite forward and an elite defenseman: Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar, Kirill Kaprizov and Quinn Hughes, Connor McDavid and Evan Bouchard.
But the Islanders are built differently.
They don’t have a superstar forward commanding the type of money that comes with being one of the NHL’s premier offensive talents.
Given how their forwards are playing right now, I genuinely believe adding another defensive difference-maker is the better play.
That doesn’t mean they should ignore opportunities to upgrade offensively, but Schaefer has already shown how much one truly elite defenseman can change this team’s complexion.
Now imagine having another one.
Thursday night’s injury to Pulock was another reminder of how quickly things can change on the Islanders’ blue line.
While there’s no telling how long Pulock might be out, the bigger issue isn’t about replacing him, Romanov or anyone else currently sidelined.
It’s about building a defensive corps that can help this team contend for years to come.
The Islanders have their franchise defenseman in Schaefer. The next step should be finding someone who can help him carry this blue line for years to come.
Edvinsson has the potential to be that guy.
We’ll see if Darche can make a splash.









Edvinsson Is a nice player no doubt. The price is going to be ridiculous if Detroit even trades him. Honestly, Detroit may not move him until the offseason. They are in an ugly standoff with their players, all of their own making!!! The Romanov injury is beyond disappointing for both him and the organization. Look you have to let him recover and see if he re-establishes himself as a starter. Then you can decide if his future is here or somewhere else. The Pulock Injury situation is Romanov Lite. Both may never recover their form simply because of their long injury histories. Neither is dependable at this point, because their availability is always in question. Romanov out for seasons, Pulock nursing constant injuries. The Immediate solution to replace one of those spots is Isiah George. Plug him into the lineup and leave him there the rest of the season. We have to commit to the young man, I think he will play extremely well. As far as Ritchie and Danny Nelson I don’t rob Peter to Pay Paul! That’s two very good young centers with guaranteed NHL level talent. Aitcheson is a Tone Setter one that plays with a fire 🔥 that is rarely seen anymore. UBS is going to explode when this kid hits the ice. Stanley has been missed big time. I cannot calculate how big of a signing he was, great job by Darche. Stanley - Schaefer. Pelech - Pulock(If Healthy) Tony D if he isn’t, and I’m not a fan of Tony D big Defensive Liability. George - Kessel or Hutton. Staple George to that third pair and play that kid period No Sheltering. Aitcheson could be a call up the latter part of this season. How smart does the drafting of Gustafsson look now. Of course he needs time, but he could be a factor in training camp next year. We all know the Defense has to get younger and be completely turned over. The question is do we have the pieces in the organization or do we need to go outside. My opinion is we don’t, even though the short term might be a little rocky.
Stanley. - Schaefer
Aitcheson - George
Gustafsson- Dravecky
Pelech is so damn good and important you hope he stays healthy the rest of his contract. That Romanov injury looms very large! Let’s stay the course. The Red Wings seem embarrassed and in a punitive mode. I think that Edvinsson sits out the NHL year, and plays in Sweden. Larkin who knows he will eventually get moved. Detroit is a messy situation indeed!
Interesting that you didn’t mention I George as trade bait. Has his stock fallen or is he untouchable? Assuming you project Eiserman to become Palmieri in his prime, we keep him. Would Detroit take George, Aitcheson and a couple of #1 picks? I’d hate to lose Ritchie.