Schaefer Showing He’s The Islanders' Difference-Maker

Matthew Schaefer’s resilience, heavy usage, and late goal highlight why the Islanders’ expectations—and future—have changed, for the better.

Stefen Rosner, David Kolb, and The Elmonters

Jan 14, 2026

∙ Paid

The New York Islanders have longed for a defenseman like Matthew Schaefer since Denis Potvin retired in 1988.

It wasn’t just elite, on-ice, two-way ability the franchise was missing. They needed a renewed sense of energy. Excitement. Quite frankly, they needed a superstar—someone whose will to win is immeasurable.

They needed an anchor. They got a strong one.

Schaefer Showing He’s The Islanders' Difference-Maker

Matthew Schaefer’s resilience, heavy usage, and late goal highlight why the Islanders’ expectations—and future—have changed, for the better.

This post is for paid subscribers