The Islanders Don’t Need An Enforcer To Protect Matthew Schaefer — Here’s Why
Calls for an Islanders enforcer are growing, but the team’s unity — and Schaefer’s poise — show why one isn’t necessary.
New York Islanders No. 1 overall pick Matthew Schaefer has become an attraction. Unfortunately for No. 48, his elite talents have also made him a target — one that’s gotten bigger and bigger with each passing game.
After Detroit Red Wings forward Mason Appleton went after Schaefer in the dying seconds of the Islanders’ 7–2 rout on Thursday, the Philadelphia Flyers collectively followed suit in what was ultimately a 4–3 shootout loss for Long Island.
After that Flyers scrum, Schaefer found himself in the penalty box for the first time in his NHL career.
General manager Mathieu Darche and head coach Patrick Roy deliberately chose veteran, big-body defenseman Scott Mayfield as Schaefer’s starting partner because of his ability to protect the youngster when needed.
And although Mayfield has done a great job supporting the young blueliner, he isn’t always on the ice with him. The two have logged 107:21 minutes together at 5-on-5, but Schaefer has also played 21:24 minutes without No. 24 beside him.
As you’ve seen in both clips above, Schaefer’s teammates continue to come to his defense. And to his credit, the rookie has shown an innate ability not to let anything affect his next shift.
“I thought he kept his focus,” Islanders head coach Patrick Roy said. “I also like the way our guys responded as well. I mean, that’s what you want to see. They’re a group that sticks together, and when those things happen, everybody is there. Nobody pulls away.”
The Enforcer Question
Despite this family-style bond, fans have wondered whether the Islanders need to add an enforcer—a Ross Johnston-type player—to protect Schaefer.
While I understand the sentiment, there’s one major reason why adding an enforcer isn’t the right move for Schaefer or the team. Actually, there are a few.